Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue Are Reportedly Engaged

Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue are reportedly engaged after dating for three years, according to reports attributed to The Los Angeles Times, USA Today, The New York Times, and E! News.

The engagement has attracted attention because Fiebig was previously married to T.J. Holmes, while Shue was previously married to Amy Robach. Holmes and Robach are former television personalities associated with Good Morning America and a widely publicized relationship story.

What the Reports Say

The available coverage identifies Fiebig and Shue as engaged and says they dated for three years before becoming engaged. It does not provide a confirmed wedding date, ceremony plans, proposal details, engagement-ring information, or a complete account of how they met.

The supplied Los Angeles Times material identifies October 21, 2026, as the coverage date. That date and the original article should be verified before publication because the supplied link is a Google News redirect rather than a direct article URL.

Source 1 — Los Angeles Times report

A separate USA Today report also says the couple became engaged after dating for three years Source 3. E! News similarly identifies Shue as Robach’s former husband and Fiebig as Holmes’ former wife Source 9. The supplied material also attributes coverage to The New York Times Source 7.

A further report states that Shue and Fiebig, described as the former spouses of Robach and Holmes, are engaged after dating for three years Source 5.

Because several outlets may have relied on the same underlying report or syndicated material, their coverage should not automatically be treated as four independent confirmations.

Why Four Outlets Are Not Four Confirmations

Multiple bylines on the same story can create a false impression of corroboration. Independent confirmation requires separate sourcing chains: separate interviews, separate documents, or separate direct statements. The supplied summaries do not show that such separation exists. They show consistent wording — engagement plus a three-year relationship — which is what syndication, aggregation, or shared source material produces.

Practical consequence for coverage: attribute the claim, do not assert it. “Reportedly engaged” and “according to reports” are accurate. “Confirmed” is not, unless a direct statement or a verified original article supports it.

How to Verify Before Publication

1. Open the original Los Angeles Times article from the publisher’s own domain rather than the Google News redirect, and confirm the October 21, 2026 date.
2. Check whether the USA Today, New York Times, and E! News pieces carry their own sourcing or repeat the same origin.
3. Look for any direct statement from Fiebig, Shue, or their representatives. The supplied material contains none.
4. Re-check whether the three-year figure is attributed to a source or presented as established fact.
5. Only then decide whether the headline reads “engaged” or “reportedly engaged.”

Who Are Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue?

Fiebig is identified in the supplied coverage as Holmes’ former wife. Shue is identified as Robach’s former husband. Their reported engagement connects the two former marriages:

• Fiebig was previously married to T.J. Holmes.
• Shue was previously married to Amy Robach.
• Fiebig and Shue are reportedly engaged.

The available reports do not support additional claims about their careers, family lives, private communications, or current relationships with their former spouses.

What the Reports Establish — and What They Do Not

The reporting establishes a relationship status and a rough duration. It does not establish how the couple met, who introduced them, where they live, how their families are involved, or how their former spouses responded. Those gaps matter because engagement stories invite speculation, and speculation about private individuals carries risk.

A useful editorial test: every sentence about Fiebig or Shue should be traceable to a specific supplied report or removed. Under that test, most color about the couple would be removed, and the piece would rest on the engagement claim and the three-year duration.

How the Two Former Marriages Are Connected

Person	Reported relationship connection
Marilee Fiebig	Former wife of T.J. Holmes
Andrew Shue	Former husband of Amy Robach
T.J. Holmes	Former husband of Marilee Fiebig
Amy Robach	Former wife of Andrew Shue

Fiebig and Shue are not reported to be related. Their connection comes through their previous marriages to Holmes and Robach.

The engagement should not be described as retaliation, revenge, or a deliberate response to the former spouses’ relationship. The available sources do not establish a motive.

Chronology Is Not Causation

One report frames the engagement as following the scandal involving the former Good Morning America hosts Source 7. Sequence in time is not evidence of intent. Two people who divorced can later marry without their decision being about anyone else. Coverage that implies otherwise asserts a motive the reporting does not supply.

Reported Dating Timeline

One supplied report says Fiebig and Shue dated for three years before becoming engaged. That description indicates the approximate length of their relationship but does not establish an exact start date.

The available summaries do not confirm:

• How the couple met
• When they began dating
• Their first public appearance together
• The proposal details
• The engagement ring
• Their wedding plans

These details should not be inferred without confirmation from reliable original sources.

Reading the Three-Year Figure

“Three years” is a duration, not a date. It supports a statement such as “the couple dated for about three years before the engagement,” and it does not support a specific month or year for the start of the relationship. If an exact start date matters to a piece, it must come from a source that states it. Rounding a duration into a calendar date is an inference, and inferences about private individuals are the easiest errors to correct publicly and the hardest to correct quietly.

Background on Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes

Robach and Holmes are former television personalities associated with Good Morning America. Their previous marriages provide the connection between Fiebig and Shue and explain the media interest in the engagement.

The supplied summaries refer to a widely reported relationship controversy involving Robach and Holmes but do not provide a complete timeline or detailed evidence. Coverage should avoid presenting unverified allegations or private information as fact.

Why the Story Draws Coverage

The news value sits in the pairing of two people already known to the public as the former spouses of a heavily covered couple. The engagement is a development in a story audiences have followed, and the reports treat it as such Source 3. That framing explains the attention without requiring any claim about the couple’s private motives.

What Has Not Been Reported

The supplied material does not confirm:

• A wedding date
• A venue
• Ceremony or reception plans
• Proposal details
• Engagement-ring information
• A direct statement from Fiebig or Shue
• Comments from Robach or Holmes
• How Fiebig and Shue met
• A complete relationship timeline
• The couple’s future plans

The records identified as Source 2, Source 4, Source 6, Source 8, and Source 10 concern unrelated or context-free material and should not be used in coverage of the engagement.

Questions Reporters Should Ask

Whether either principal has issued a statement through a representative. Whether the engagement is confirmed by a named source or only by repetition across outlets. Whether the three-year duration originates with the couple or with a secondary report. Whether any supplied record actually concerns the engagement — several do not, and including them would introduce unrelated material into a celebrity story.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue engaged?

According to reports attributed to several news organizations, Marilee Fiebig and Andrew Shue are reportedly engaged. The original reports should be reviewed before the engagement is described as confirmed.

How are Fiebig and Shue connected to Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes?

Fiebig was previously married to T.J. Holmes, while Shue was previously married to Amy Robach. Their reported engagement connects the two former marriages.

How long did they date before getting engaged?

One supplied report says Fiebig and Shue dated for three years before becoming engaged. The exact start date has not been established in the available summaries.

Was Andrew Shue married to Amy Robach?

Yes. The supplied reports identify Andrew Shue as Amy Robach’s former husband.

Was Marilee Fiebig married to T.J. Holmes?

Yes. The supplied reports identify Marilee Fiebig as T.J. Holmes’ former wife.

Do they have a wedding date?

The available reports do not provide a confirmed wedding date or ceremony plans.

Did Fiebig or Shue comment publicly?

The supplied material contains no direct statement from either of them. Any quote attributed to the couple would require a verified original source.

Did Robach or Holmes comment on the engagement?

The supplied material contains no comment from Robach or Holmes. Their connection to the story is through their previous marriages, not through any reported reaction.

When did the coverage appear?

The supplied Los Angeles Times material identifies October 21, 2026, as the coverage date. That date should be checked against the original article before it is cited.